“Collaboration is an interactive process that engages two or more participants to work together to achieve outcomes that are difficult to accomplish independently” (Salmons, 2009). Without cooperation and communication, we cannot successfully participate in online collaborative learning. According to Hurst & Thomas (2008), “to make this process work, individuals must engage in self-monitoring, team process monitoring, and proactive commitment to the work of learning (p. 460). Therefore, the assessment of a collaborative project should be evaluated in three ways. First, a group grade should be given for producing a final project collaboratively. Second, an individual grade should be assigned for each person’s overall contribution to the group project. George Siemens refers to this type of assessment as a balanced diet – a mixture of individual and community-based assignments (Laureate Education, 2008). When people realize that there are consequences for not working together, they will be more willing to compromise and complete their part of the work. Third, a self-assessment grade should be completed using a rating scale and a journal component that evaluates academic growth, collaboration skills, and strategies for improvement (Palloff & Pratt, 2005, p. 43).
An instructor, who is grading students of varying levels, should strongly focus on feedback. Every grade will be fair and equitable, if the instructor gives each student what he or she needs to be successful. For example, if only one person needs CPR, I would not give it to everyone, just the person, who needed it. The same philosophy applies for education; some students need help with writing, audio instructions, or assistance with technology, but not everyone needs the same accommodations. Academic instruction is becoming an individualized process where communication is required to reach a specific goal. When feedback focuses on encouraging, correcting, and challenging learners, it will be fair and equitable for all students (Marzano, Pickering, & Pollock, 2001).
If a classmate does not want to participate in the online learning community, classmates should ask why, and identify ways to encourage the struggling student. I would recommend praising the student for good ideas that he or she mentioned earlier, or reminding this student of how people can accomplish more when they work together. According to Palloff & Pratt (2007), conflict in online learning communities must be addressed, so that effective cohesion and learning can occur (p. 39). If a student continues to be resistant after group members have tried to encourage participation, the instructor should intervene and notify this student. I believe consequences should be given if the student does not complete assignments correctly. We must remember “Online instructors cannot deliver knowledge; online learners must seek it out” (Styers, 2004 as quoted in Palloff & Pratt, p. 3). If students are not motivated to learn and participate, a person’s grade and success should suffer.
Hurst, D., & Thomas, J. (2008). Developing team skills and accomplishing team projects online. In T. Anderson (Ed.), The theory and practice of online learning (2nd ed., pp. 441–472). Edmonton, AB: Athabasca University Press.
Laureate Education, Inc. (2008). Assessment of Collaborative Learning. Principles of Distance Education. Baltimore: Author.
Marzano, R. J., Pickering, D. J., Pollock, J. E., (2001). Feedback. Classroom Instruction that works: Research-based strategies for increasing student achievement. Danvers, MA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development pp. 99-102.
Palloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (2005). Collaborating online: Learning together in community. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass. p. 43.
Palloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (2007). Recontextualizing community. In Building online learning communities: Effective strategies for the virtual classroom (pp. 25–44). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Salmons, J. (2009) How did we work? Assessing collaborative projects in class or the workplace. Vision2Lead.com, Inc. Retrieved from
http://www.educause.edu/sites/default/files/library/presentations/ELIX09/GS11/wework.pdf
Styers, A. (2004, April). Unpublished comprehensive paper. Capella University.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
So what happens in a group project? I think that is adequately stated when it's individual work however, does the same principle apply when in a group? I have a couple of students who do not participate in a group in my classroom and I have tried everything: contract, candy, extra time on computer, recess etc etc. I don't feel it's fair when the group has tried to reach out to this ind. and so have I, for the whole group to be penalized. Therefore, when it's group time, he's placed at a different point of the room, asked to perform an individual piece of work comparable to the group work assigned. Either way, they are required to do the work. His "group" grade suffers but he's given credit for the individual effort by himself. Is that wrong?
ReplyDeleteAndy
ReplyDeleteI know that I do not know this student, so it difficult to say whether it is wrong to let the student work independently. For this reason, I have mixed opinions about this situation. If the student is going to shut down completely and refuse to learn, it would be better if he worked alone. On the other hand, this student needs to learn how to collaborate with others regardless of his or her personal desires. “No man is an island, entire of itself” (Donne, 1624). We cannot go through life doing everything independently. Learning how to cooperate with others is a life skill that cannot be avoided regardless of age, gender, or learning environment. Therefore, I would not let the student work alone, I would make him stay with the group and receive a low grade for not participating properly or send him to the office for refusing to work or follow directions. Everyone is resistant to change at times and tries to buck the system. To avoid this behavior, I believe we should strive to develop personal relationships with people we learn or teach with. What subject or concept will make the student talk? The other ideas I might consider would be to pose thinking questions such as can you win a football game by playing by yourself or if you share the work, would it take less time? The goal of communication F2F or online is to develop a safe learning environment, so that students see communicating with peers and instructors as a natural and enjoyable way to learn (Palloff & Pratt, 2007).
Donne, J. (1624). Mediation XVII.
Palloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (2007). Recontextualizing community. In Building online learning communities: Effective strategies for the virtual classroom (pp. 25–44). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Amy,
ReplyDeleteI love the quote, "online instructors cannot deliver knowledge; online learners must seek it out". I never looked at distance education in that matter but I find it very true. What are some reasons do you think some students may not participate in collaborative assignments?
Deidre Buckhalter
Amy,
ReplyDeleteI think you have identified three critical aspects of collaborative exercises and their related assessment. Identifying a well-defined collaborative project is central to delineating the process of its progression and the nature of its assessment. The question, “What did it take for the group to achieve a learning objective collaboratively?” is equally important to ask as the one that merely determines if the group met the objective. I do not see equity in this regard for effective and meaningful collaborative assessment. The individual component of the collaborative assessment, I think, must have objective inputs both from the instructor and from the members of the collaborative community. Boix-Mansilla (http://www.evergreen.edu/washcenter/resources/upload/Productive_Shifts_-_Boix-Mansilla2.pdf) argued that progressive inquiry into students’ work leads to conceptual change regarding assessment and expertise in a discipline. Consequently, a student earns a grade based on individual contribution and interpersonal interaction that leads to collaborative assessment of the group’s collective grade. I whole-heartedly agree with self-assessment Palloff and Pratt’s recommendation regarding self-assessment. Particularly when most of us are active educators, self-reflection models the expectation of our students and, consequently, as students enhanced efficacy in the process of which each of us is an integral and collaborative part. Vidmar’s article (see http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=EJ744969&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=EJ744969 ) for an abstract) highlighted the nature of reflective peer coaching that helps formulate collaborative self-assessment in teaching.
Thank you and best regards
David Abraham (Blog response in Module #3)
Deidre
ReplyDeleteThere are several reasons why I think students refuse to participate in collaborative environments.
1. Students feel inferior to other group members, or embarrassed by lack of skills.
2. Students feel used by other group members not willing to do their part. (Ex. One person doing all the work)
3. Students might be shy and scared to communicate with others.
4. Fear of being embarrassed by saying or writing the wrong thing.
Asking "why" is indeed a way to determine why students may not be participating in collaborative learning. If you read my blog, I stated that the reason I was not participating with my group was because of the lack of knowledge I had working with wikispaces. I was not just not wanting to participate, I had a reason...spending hours trying to figure out how to add a comment or post my assignments. Asking why gets down to the root of the issue of lack of participation inside of a group environment. You will indeed get an answer, it may not be the one you were seeking (when dealing with high school age students) but it will help you determine why the student is not comfortable in participation in the group.
ReplyDeleteI have run into the problem being an educator and letting individuals rate each other as far as the individual grade is concerned and the overall group grade. Parents would complain about their child being penalized for lack of work done by others in the group. Or, they would complain that their child is doing all of the work but received a low rate from their peer evaluations. How do you explain to parents or adult learners about the entire group grade and individual grade when dealing with collaborative instruction? I have been struggling with this for years, even when I give the students a rubric!